Infectious Diseases as Weapons:

What Every Physician Should Know

 

Jeffrey W. Waguespack, M.D.

LSU Medical Center, Shreveport, Louisiana

January 22, 1999 


  1. Overview
    1. Why discuss Biological Weapons?
      1. Recent events have put biological and chemical warfare agents in the spotlight (Iraq, Persian Gulf War)
      2. Susceptibility to terrorism evident (Oklahoma City, New York, militia and cult groups)
      3. Primary suspected agents of bioweapons produce a spectrum of diseases that are problematic to diagnose because they are rarely occurring naturally and often mimic other diseases
      4. Health care professionals and public health authorities must be aware of the threat of BW and terrorism in order to minimize the effects of the biological attack
      5. Physicians will most likely be first line in recognizing diseases resulting from biological agents
    2. Common Misconceptions about Biological Weapons
      1. Rarely used in past, so won’t be used in future
      2. Will not be used because use is morally repugnant
      3. Production and dispersion too technically difficult
      4. Potential destructiveness unthinkable and so dismissed
    3. Realities of Biological Terrorism and Warfare
      1. Use more likely than ever and more threatening than conventional weapons
      2. Official actions to prevent marginally funded and supported
      3. Agents easy to obtain and are inexpensive
      4. Detection or interdiction next to impossible


  2. Historical Perspective
    1. Pre-Modern Era
      1. 5th century B.C. Greco-Romans contaminated water sources with animal carcasses
      2. 400 B.C. Scythian archers "weaponized" biological agents by dipping arrowheads in feces and cadavers
      3. 190 B.C. Hannibal launched pottery with poisonous snakes onto enemy ships
      4. 14th century Monguls catapulted plague infected cadavers into the Ukrainian city of Kaffa
      5. 1763 British officers gave blankets infected with smallpox to Native Americans during French and Indian War
      6. 1860s US Civil War Confederate surgeon imported clothes infected with yellow fever
    2. Biological Weapon use during the 20th century
      1. WW I Germany used Bacillus anthracis (anthrax) and B. mallei (glanders) to infect livestock and animal feed exported to Allies
      2. 1932 – 1945 Japan conducted research on B. anthracis, N. meningitidis, Shigella spp, V. cholera and Y. pestis
      3. 1942 Britain developed strategic amounts of anthrax
      4. 1940s Nazi prisoners infected with Rickettsia spp, hepatitis A, Plasmodia spp and treated with investigational vaccines and drugs
      5. 1940s Nazi secret agent Reinhardt Heydrich assassinated with botulinum toxin
    3. US Biological Weapons Program
      1. 1942 approximately 5000 bombs filled with B. anthracis produced
      2. 1950s program expanded during Korean War
      3. 1955 human experiments with F. tularensis and C. burnetti
      4. 1949 – 1968 simulant organism released off coast of San Francisco and in New York City subway
      5. 1969 US terminated offensive biological weapons program
      6. 1972 Biological Weapons Convention and Treaty


  3. Is the threat real?
    1. By 1995 17 countries suspected to have biological weapons
    2. 1984 members of a cult contaminated salad bars in Oregon restaurants with Salmonella spp
    3. 1995 Japanese cult found to have botulinum toxin and anthrax cultures and to have researched the use of Ebola virus for weapons use
    4. 1995 Lab technician in Ohio ordered 3 vials of Y. pestis through the mail
    5. 1995 two members of Minnesota militia group convicted of possession of ricin


  4. Review of Potential Biological Weapon Agents
    1. Anthrax
    1. Smallpox (Variola)
    1. Plague
    1. Q Fever
    1. Tularemia
    1. Viral Encephalitides
    1. Viral Hemorrhagic Fevers (VHF)
    1. Botulinum Toxin


  1. Key Elements of a Biological Weapon
    1. Payload (biological agent)
    2. Munition (container that keeps the payload intact and virulent during delivery)
    3. Delivery system (missile, artillery shell, aircraft, etc.)
    4. Dispersal mechanism (explosive force or spray device)


  2. Characteristics of Biological Weapons that make them Attractive to Countries and Terrorists
    1. Cost efficiency
      1. Requires $10000 worth of equipment and a 16 x 16 ft. room to manufacture
      2. Cost figures for production of mass casualties
        1. Conventional Weapons = $2000/sq. km
        2. Nuclear Weapons = $800/sq. km
        3. Chemical Weapons = $600/sq. km
        4. Biological Weapons = $1/sq. km
    2. Large number of casualties
      1. 10 grams of anthrax can kill as many people as 900 kg of sarin
      2. If 900 kg of sarin was released over Washington D.C. estimated 2000-8000 deaths, if anthrax used would result in 1-3 million deaths
    3. Biological weapon agents are invisible, odorless and tasteless once released


  3. Defense Against Biological Weapons
    1. Respirator or gas mask
    2. Protective shelter
    3. Decontamination
    4. Vaccination
    5. Antibiotics
    6. Detection systems


Bibliography

Breman JG and Henderson DA. Poxvirus dilemmas-monkeypox, smallpox and biological terrorism. NEJM. 1998; 339:556-559.

Christopher GW, et al. Biological warfare: a historical perspective. JAMA. 1997; 278:412-417.

Cole LA. The specter of biological weapons. Scientific American. 1996; Dec:60-65.

Franz DR, et al. clinical recognition and management of patients exposed to biological warfare agents. JAMA. 1997; 278:399-409.

Henderson DA. Bioterrorism as a public health threat. Emerging Infectious Diseases. 1998; 4:488-492.

Lesho E, et al. Feces, dead horses and fleas: evolution of the hostile use of biological agents. WJM. 1998; 168:512-516.

Pile JC, et al. Anthrax as a potential biological warfare agent. Arch Intern Med. 1998; 158:429-434.

Simon JD. Biological terrorism: preparing to meet the threat. JAMA. 1997; 278:428-430.

Zilinakas RA. Iraq’s biological weapons: the past as future? JAMA. 1997; 278:418-423.


LSUMC Family Medicine Grand Rounds Home Page

Return to LSUMC-S Clinical and Academic Medicine Home Page

Return to the LSUMC-S Home Page.